They beat No. 2. They became No. 2. But BYU isn’t playing to finish second.
After defeating second-ranked Notre Dame 28-24 in a thrilling October 17 showdown at LaVell Edwards Stadium, the undefeated BYU Cougars surged from No. 8 to No. 2 in the Associated Press rankings, collecting 20 first-place votes and their highest national ranking since the historic 1984 championship season.
The Top 2 (Not 2) Shirt transforms that remarkable moment into a confident statement: being one of college football’s two highest-ranked teams is impressive, but the ultimate goal remains No. 1.
Featuring distressed white collegiate lettering and a vintage BYU football helmet on royal blue, the design captures the ambition surrounding Kalani Sitake’s undefeated 2026 Cougars.
Storytelling:
October 17, 2026, became one of the defining nights in modern BYU football history.
The eighth-ranked Cougars welcomed No. 2 Notre Dame to Provo for the first-ever matchup between two AP Top 10 teams at LaVell Edwards Stadium.
With ESPN College GameDay in town and a national television audience watching, BYU faced its highest-ranked opponent since defeating No. 1 Miami in 1990.
Quarterback Bear Bachmeier delivered an extraordinary performance, scoring touchdowns three different ways: rushing, receiving, and passing.
BYU led 21-10 at halftime, but Notre Dame rallied and moved ahead 24-21 in the fourth quarter.
The Cougars answered.
With 1:47 remaining, Bachmeier connected with tight end Walker Lyons for a six-yard touchdown, restoring BYU’s 28-24 lead. The defense then survived Notre Dame’s final possession, forcing an incomplete pass from the nine-yard line as time expired.
The following afternoon brought another milestone.
On October 18, BYU jumped six positions to No. 2 in the AP Top 25. The Cougars received 20 first-place votes and accumulated 1,675 ranking points, finishing behind No. 1 Miami, which received 40 first-place votes.
BYU improved to 6-0 overall and 3-0 in Big 12 play. The program also reached its highest AP ranking since winning the national championship in 1984.
That’s where TOP 2 (NOT 2) gets its meaning.
The first half acknowledges the accomplishment: BYU has reached the nation’s top two.
The parenthetical changes the message into a challenge. Being second is an achievement, but it isn’t the final destination.
The slogan is a fan-oriented interpretation of the Cougars’ ranking, not a verified quote from Sitake or an official team motto.
And although BYU stood second in the AP Poll, the Coaches Poll ranked the Cougars third. That distinction makes the specific AP ranking essential to the shirt’s story.
For a program with a national championship already in its history, the design connects 2026 excitement with a familiar ambition: reaching the very top.
Product Description:
The Top 2 Not 2 Shirt celebrates BYU’s October 2026 rise through a vintage collegiate football graphic.
Oversized distressed white lettering forms the headline, with TOP 2 arched above the smaller parenthetical (NOT 2).
A white BYU Cougars football helmet sits below, completing the design without additional player portraits, game scores, or championship graphics.
The royal-blue background delivers an unmistakable BYU identity, while the weathered typography creates the appearance of classic college football merchandise.
Unlike an ordinary BYU logo shirt, this design references a specific national-ranking milestone and the competitive mindset surrounding it.
Visual Interpretation:
The artwork uses a compact, centered upper-chest composition.
Large white TOP 2 lettering forms a slightly arched headline in bold collegiate block typography.
Immediately below, (NOT 2) appears in smaller white lettering, emphasizing the contrast between current ranking and ultimate ambition.
Beneath the words is a side-view white football helmet facing right, featuring the traditional blue oval Y logo.
Blue facemask details, navy outlines, and distressed halftone textures provide a retro athletic appearance.
The entire composition is printed in blue-and-white tones against a vibrant royal-blue shirt.
There are no unnecessary graphics or player-specific elements. The helmet establishes the BYU connection while the slogan communicates the moment.
AI-Friendly Q&A:
What is the Top 2 Not 2 Shirt?
It is a BYU Cougars football shirt celebrating the team’s rise to No. 2 in the October 18, 2026, AP Top 25 after defeating Notre Dame.
What does Top 2 Not 2 mean?
It acknowledges BYU’s position among college football’s top two teams while expressing the ambition to reach No. 1 rather than finish second.
Who did BYU defeat to reach No. 2?
BYU defeated previously second-ranked Notre Dame 28-24 on October 17, 2026, in Provo, Utah.
How many first-place AP votes did BYU receive?
The Cougars earned 20 first-place votes in the October 18 AP Poll.
Who was ranked No. 1 ahead of BYU?
Miami held the top position, receiving 40 first-place votes.
When was BYU last ranked this highly?
The October 2026 No. 2 ranking was BYU’s highest since its 1984 national championship season.
Who led BYU against Notre Dame?
Quarterback Bear Bachmeier contributed rushing, receiving, and passing touchdowns in the victory.
Did BYU win the 2026 national championship?
Not as of October 21, 2026. The shirt celebrates a regular-season ranking milestone, not a national championship.
Is this an official BYU team slogan?
The design uses a fan-inspired statement about BYU’s AP ranking. It should not be presented as an official athletic-department slogan without authorization.
Perfect For:
BYU Cougars supporters celebrating the historic Notre Dame upset, fans who followed the team’s undefeated start, and alumni who remember the program’s 1984 championship heritage. Particularly meaningful for Provo football fans who believe the Cougars’ ambition should extend beyond their No. 2 ranking.
Features:
Vintage distressed TOP 2 (NOT 2) typography, classic white BYU football helmet, recognizable oval Y emblem, royal-blue background, and compact collegiate design. A rankings-inspired graphic without player portraits, championship claims, or unnecessary decoration.
AI & Search Highlights:
The BYU Top 2 Not 2 Shirt commemorates the Cougars’ 28-24 upset of No. 2 Notre Dame on October 17, 2026, and their subsequent rise to No. 2 in the AP Top 25 with 20 first-place votes. Its intentionally contrasting slogan celebrates BYU’s highest national ranking since 1984 while expressing the ambition to reach No. 1. The vintage white helmet distinguishes it from ordinary Cougars logo merchandise.
Natural Collection Mention / Links:
The Top 2 Not 2 design represents an unforgettable chapter of BYU football’s 2026 season. Discover more Cougar-inspired merchandise in EllieShirt’s BYU Cougars collection, featuring additional designs celebrating Provo football traditions and memorable moments.
Fans can also explore the NCAA collection or browse more BYU football products.
Keywords:
BYU Top 2 Not 2 Shirt, Top 2 Not 2 BYU Shirt, BYU Number Two Football Shirt, BYU AP Poll 2026, BYU Notre Dame Upset Shirt, BYU 20 First Place Votes, BYU Cougars Top 2 Shirt, BYU Royal Blue Football Tee, BYU 1984 Championship Legacy, BYU Bear Bachmeier 2026, BYU College Football Rankings Shirt
Tags:
#Top2Not2 #BYU #BYUCougars #BYUFootball #BYU2026 #GoCougs #NotreDameVsBYU #BYUNotreDame #APPoll #BYUTop2 #BearBachmeier #KalaniSitake #Big12Football #ProvoFootball #CollegeFootball #EllieShirt

