The Night Joe Musgrove’s Ear Became Part of Padres History

San Diego remembers October 9, 2022 for seven scoreless innings, one hit allowed and a Wild Card Series victory. Baseball remembers one more detail: an umpire grabbing Joe Musgrove’s ear in the middle of the most important start of his career.

Playoff baseball produces photographs that become shorthand for entire nights. Joe Musgrove’s winner-take-all start against the Mets produced one of the strangest. Crew chief Alfonso Márquez stood beside the mound with his hand against Musgrove’s ear while tens of thousands of people at Citi Field tried to understand why a pitcher dominating New York was suddenly receiving what looked like an extremely serious ear examination.

Mets manager Buck Showalter had asked the umpiring crew to inspect Musgrove for a foreign substance. Television cameras had noticed that his ears appeared shiny, and New York was searching for some explanation for why its lineup could barely touch him.

The umpires checked his hat, hands, face and ears. They found nothing illegal. Musgrove returned to work.

That final sentence is why the incident became Padres folklore instead of controversy. He finished seven innings, allowed one hit, permitted no runs and helped San Diego win 6–0 to eliminate the Mets. MLB later noted that he became the first pitcher to throw at least seven scoreless innings while allowing only one hit in a winner-take-all postseason game.

Buck Showalter Was Searching for Anything That Might Change the Game

The context matters. This was not an ordinary June start. Game 3 decided the entire Wild Card Series. The loser’s season was over.

Through five innings, Musgrove had allowed one hit. His velocity and spin had both increased modestly compared with regular-season averages, and Showalter asked the umpires to check him.

Musgrove did not argue his way into becoming the hero. He simply allowed the inspection. Crew chief Márquez later confirmed that the crew found nothing. Musgrove described the shine on his ears as sweat.

External Source — MLB Musgrove’s official MLB profile still connects one of San Diego’s most recognizable pitchers to a postseason résumé whose defining road performance remains the 2022 Wild Card masterpiece in New York.

The Inspection Only Made the Performance More Memorable

Showalter’s tactic had an understandable competitive logic. If the Mets believed something unusual was happening, waiting until after elimination would accomplish nothing. The check itself followed MLB’s foreign-substance procedures.

But from San Diego’s perspective, the result was almost cinematic. The accusation arrived, the umpires searched, nothing was discovered, and Musgrove became even more dominant afterward.

The Padres entered the clubhouse with a six-run victory and a ticket to the NLDS. Manny Machado later poured champagne over Musgrove while joking about “sticky stuff.” The bizarre interruption had already shifted from suspicion into celebration material.

Years later, references to “the ear game” still appear whenever Padres fans discuss Musgrove’s defining moments. Even a 2026 thread celebrating his ten years of MLB service time immediately brought back two memories: San Diego’s first no-hitter and the night the Mets had his ears inspected before he shut them out.

“Hold My Ear” Is Design Language, Not a Verified Musgrove Quote

The Hold My Ear Shirt turns the visual memory into a punch line. It is important, though, to separate the artwork from the historical record: “Hold My Ear” should not be presented as a documented quote Musgrove said during the game.

The phrase works as a retrospective meme because viewers already know the image. You do not need to reproduce Showalter’s strategic reasoning. You only need Musgrove, an ear and the absurd memory of a postseason umpire inspection.

The artwork takes one of the strangest inspection images in MLB postseason history and reduces it to instant Padres shorthand: Musgrove, the ear, and the night New York searched for an answer it never found. View the playoff-memory piece →

Why the Moment Still Matters While Musgrove Works Back in 2026

The current Musgrove story is very different. He is not dominating postseason hitters right now. He has spent much of 2026 working back from Tommy John surgery and a spring setback.

MLB reported in late July that Musgrove had progressed to facing hitters, with a possible return later in August or September. That makes his older playoff images emotionally useful in a different way. Padres fans are waiting to see whether No. 44 can add another chapter, so the established chapters carry more weight while he rehabs.

Musgrove is especially tied to San Diego because he is local. Born in El Cajon, he became the pitcher who delivered the first no-hitter in Padres franchise history in 2021 and then produced one of the greatest postseason starts the club has ever received the following year.

That is why an ear joke can survive four seasons. It is attached to more than a funny screenshot. It is attached to a pitcher San Diego already considered its own.

The San Diego Padres collection captures those postseason memories and current Petco Park personalities, while the broader MLB collection follows the moments that become permanent fan-language long after the original box score disappears.

Frequently Asked Questions