Daaa Pope: Miguel Vargas Gave White Sox Pope Night Its Perfect Baseball Moment

Forty thousand papal hats, a South Side pope, one very Chicago nickname and a Miguel Vargas home run turned an August baseball promotion into something far stranger — and far more memorable — than another giveaway night.

Before the first pitch on August 11, Rate Field already looked unlike any normal baseball stadium. Thousands of white mitres filled the seats. Signs around the park read like Chicago Catholic inside jokes. Somewhere between the South Side, the Vatican and an old Saturday Night Live accent, White Sox baseball had become Pope Night.

The promotion existed because Pope Leo XIV is not simply the first American pope. Robert Francis Prevost is a Chicago native whose baseball loyalty belongs to the White Sox, a fact that became national sports news almost immediately after his election in May 2025.

Then Miguel Vargas supplied the baseball punctuation. In the fourth inning against Cincinnati, Vargas hit his 25th home run of the season, helping Chicago build a 4–0 lead while tens of thousands of fans watched in papal headwear.

How 2,500 Pope Hats Became 40,000

The scale of the evening tells the story better than almost anything else. Chicago originally planned Pope Night around roughly 2,500 special-ticket vouchers. Demand overwhelmed that expectation, so the White Sox kept expanding the order until the promotion became a stadium-wide giveaway.

By the time the Reds arrived, the club had enough mitre-shaped hats for virtually everyone in attendance. Fans who had purchased the original special package received an additional white “CHICAGO’S POPE” jersey with No. 14 — the number Chicago had previously used in its papal tribute.

Rate Field drew 38,113 fans, a huge crowd for a Tuesday night and an example of how a promotional object can become part of the event rather than a souvenir collected on the way inside.

Why “Daaa Pope” Sounds So Completely Chicago

The phrase predates this particular White Sox game. When Leo XIV was elected in 2025, Chicago immediately began translating a historic religious event into local dialect and sports humor.

“Da Pope” is built on the same exaggerated Chicago pronunciation as “Da Bears,” the phrase immortalized by Saturday Night Live’s Bill Swerski’s Superfans. The joke became so widespread that Chicago media, social feeds and local products began using it almost immediately.

That is why stretching the phrase into “Daaa Pope” feels natural rather than random. It sounds like a South Side fan extending the vowel across a bar, parking lot or stadium section. The wording turns a globally important religious office into the kind of person Chicago would argue about over Italian beef.

Miguel Vargas Made the Meme a Baseball Story

A successful theme night does not require the game to cooperate, but Pope Night briefly looked scripted. Brenton Doyle homered on the first pitch of the bottom of the first. Edgar Quero added another solo shot. Then Vargas went deep in the fourth.

Chicago had a 4–0 advantage and a ballpark filled with papal hats. For a few innings, divine-intervention jokes practically wrote themselves.

The ending was less miraculous. Cincinnati rallied, tied the game and eventually won 5–4 in ten innings. That does not reduce the cultural value of the night. If anything, the combination feels extremely baseball: an unforgettable visual experience attached to a result that refuses to follow the script.

The Graphic Freezes the Vargas Moment, Not the Final Score

The black version turns the Pope Night joke into a South Side poster: Vargas, Chicago baseball and papal imagery compressed into the language fans were already using around one of the strangest nights at Rate Field. View the Daaa Pope graphic →

On sport grey, the same composition feels closer to an old stadium giveaway or newspaper illustration — appropriate because Pope Night already carries the texture of an event fans may remember through photographs of the crowd as much as the box score.

The sport-grey presentation pushes the artwork toward vintage Chicago sports ephemera, letting “Daaa Pope” read like a headline from one extremely specific night in South Side history. See the sport-grey version →

Pope Leo Has Become Part of White Sox Folklore

The connection is unusually authentic for a sports marketing story. Leo was photographed at Game 1 of the 2005 World Series, long before anyone could have imagined he would later become pope. After his election, old broadcast footage also revealed him in the stands.

That turns the White Sox relationship into something better than celebrity endorsement. He was there before the papacy. He was a fan before his fandom had commercial value.

That authenticity explains why the team has leaned so aggressively into the connection and why fans have accepted the joke. The broader MLB Shirts collection tracks the same way baseball turns strange local stories, player moments and one-night promotions into fan visual culture.

Frequently Asked Questions